"[A] cozy story about forming a family. A bear couple waits for their cub to appear. When he does, Fin is a bit, well, fishier than expected. The woodland creatures initially seem skeptical, but the bears fully embrace the child they have. There’s not a moment’s hesitation as they accept their child’s differences and work to bridge experience gaps. Initially inspired by friends whose adopted son was diagnosed with a rare genetic disorder, the tale is infused with a dreamy, ethereal tone. The narrative perfectly matches the homey illustrations. Scuderi’s watercolor animals are rudimentary but appealing, with textured paper peeping through colored layers for an even more welcoming rustic feel. It adds to the earthy naturalness of the story. Why wouldn’t the bears utterly fall for their water-dwelling kiddo? And why wouldn’t their friends do the same? Any tension melts away under the warmth of their love.VERDICT A comforting story for families of all stripes, with an added educational bonus showing acceptance of all for younger elementary children."
School Library Journal

Two bears adopt an unusual cub. . . One night, “a fine thread descend[s] from a star” and deposits Mama and Papa Bear’s child at 29 Wood Lane. Though initially startled to discover their “cub” is a goldfish, the parents welcome Fin warmly. . . Scuderi’s lush paintings deftly blend realistic animal depictions and subtle emotional expressions.
Kirkus Reviews

Pages, overflowing with gossamer artwork that is nothing short of joyful ebullience, grace this very special story that celebrates the uniqueness of each individual. Rating 5 out of 5
Youth Services Book Review